In earlier years the discovery of a cancerous lump in the breast was very bad news for most women – usually they would have to undergo a mastectomy (removal of the breast), probably receive chemotherapy, and deal with all the emotional and physical tribulation cancer patients are faced with. However, modern science has shown drastic improvements in the survival rate and also the quality of life for breast cancer survivors. In the 21st Century, 80 out of 100 patients with early stage breast cancer are still alive and well after 20 years. “With the increasing survival of patients, quality of life issues become ever more important. One aspect crucial to the well-being of women is the cosmetic outcome of the cancer treatment,” explains Dr. Rika Pienaar, an oncologist in Cape Town. At comprehensive breast centres the majority of women are treated by breast conserving therapy. “The initial trials of breast conservation primarily addressed safety issues and cosmetic outcome was only a secondary consideration” says Professor Justus Apffelstaedt of the University of Stellenbosch.
According to Professor Frank Graewe, Head of the Division of Plastic Surgery of the University of Stellenbosch: “The surgical outcome initially was often acceptable. However, the necessary addition of radiotherapy in breast conservation led to progressive scarring. After a few years the scarring made the cosmetic outcome rather poor”. At times, mastectomies had to be performed to alleviate problems associated with late radiation changes.
Two developments improved the cosmetic outcome markedly: progress in radiation planning and new technology in radiation delivery that cause much less scarring than in the past and new surgical techniques that have been developed.
Where previously the aim was merely to eliminate the cancer, it is now understood that surgical treatments and radiotherapy must be integrated. The aims of this integration are the uncompromised safety in cancer treatment while establishing an aesthetically pleasing breast shape that can withstand radiotherapy with little long-term changes.
Best results from a team approach
This is most readily achieved by a team approach of an oncologic surgeon, an oncologist and a plastic surgeon, all of whom have a specialised interest in breast cancer management in order to understand the complexities involved.
“For me as the senior member and convener of such a team, it has been an eye-opener how much interaction takes place particularly between the radiation oncologist and the plastic surgeon” says Professor Apffelstaedt.
Concurs Dr Pienaar: “I have learned a lot in these combined clinics about the amazing new tools that plastic surgeons have developed. These now provide us with a reformed breast shape with excellent blood supply in which radiation is much better tolerated”.
This approach, which combines cancer surgery and plastic surgery in the same session, is called “oncoplastic” breast surgery. It was initially described in the 1990’s and is undergoing continuous refinement. Thirty years ago, breast cancer surgery was easy: It meant mastectomy. Today, lumpectomies, tumor excisions, segmentectomies, quadrantectomies, skin sparing mastectomies, mastectomies and still a lot more belong to the armamentarium of the oncologic surgeon. Likewise, the plastic surgeon has to have in his arsenal procedures ranging from local rearrangement of the breast gland after an excision of a tumour, a variety of breast reduction techniques, into which the tumour excisions are integrated, to reconstructions with own tissue or prostheses.
“Experience has taught us, that in order to provide an optimal cosmetic outcome, the plastic surgeon should be familiar with all of these different techniques,” says Professor Graewe. Even then, an unfortunate minority of women will require a mastectomy.
In these cases immediate reconstruction is the standard of care. In the newest reconstruction techniques, only skin and fat with their own blood supply are removed and used to form a new breast. No muscles are sacrificed and the recovery is swift. As donor areas for the new breast, the lower belly or the buttocks are used, which often have accumulated a little excess tissue.
But not only the volume and the shape of a breast are important. “I need an oncologic surgeon who can provide me with as much original skin as oncologically safe. This makes the newly formed breast look and above all feel more natural” says Prof. Graewe.
Breast cancer management has come a long way since the early days of breast conservation. It is the aim to restore women who are afflicted by this dreaded disease to a status as normal as possible as soon as possible. A combined approach of a radiation oncologist, a surgical oncologist and a plastic surgeon all seeing the patient together and making decisions with the patient and her family, comes close to this ideal.
More on Modern Breast Health Maintenance
Dr. Rika Pienaar is a radiation oncologist at Panorama Medi-clinic in Cape Town. After qualifying in 1985 at University of Orange Free State in Bloemfontein, she moved to Cape Town were she worked in the department of surgery of Tygerberg Hospital. She finished her specialization in Oncology in 1992 and went on to become a consultant radiation oncologist in the Breast clinic of Tygerberg Hospital. She joined Dr. Sean Brennan in private practise at Wynberg Hospital and a few years later they amalgamated with Gouws and Partners.
For more than 20 years she has had a deep interest in breast cancer. Being a nationally recognized “Opinion leader in Breast Cancer”, she has delivered more than 50 invited lectures at national meetings, colleges, universities and women's organizations. She also is an elected member of various international Advisory Boards in the field of chemotherapy and hormonal therapy of breast cancer. She collaborates in leading international research groups as co-investigator to determine the future treatment of breast cancer. She frequently attends international breast cancer meetings worldwide and continually strives for academic excellence and innovation in breast cancer management.